When most brands try to integrate their social media and traditional marketing, it’s … awkward.
Here’s a current commercial for a brand and a product I am biologically unable to connect to:
You know what helps says the hipster female comedian … Come on, ad guys.
Anyway, the spot ends with the call-to-action of “Tweet #KotexforReal“.
Really? At some point, there was a meeting of ad and social media gurus where someone said:
Let’s integrate our traditional TV ad buy with a hashtag to synergize the social experience and empower our customers to connect with our brand and talk about their menstrual cycles.
Sounds like the bookstore from Portlandia.
So I’m watching the TeeVee while I’m on the Twitter and the spot comes on. I check the hashtag.
95% of the tweets are from 14-35 year-old males who are ridiculing the spot in a vulgar way.
3% are a variation of the tweet, “The TV said I should tweet #KotexforReal”. (which is scary).
The other 2% are #TeamFollowBack and spammers.
Does a personal hygiene brand really want to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars for a TV spot that generates “free” social media mentions like this?
When you try to astroturf social media buzz, you WILL get your hashtag hijacked. Social media marketing conversations are just like any other marketing conversation with consumers. If they’re transparent, they will fail.
It reminds me of one of my favorite quotes from Hugh MacLeod: “If you talked to people the way advertising talked to people, they’d punch you in the face.”